Treatment and Outcomes of First Troponin-Negative Non–ST-Segment Elevation Myocardial Infarction




Little is known about non–ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction (MI) in patients with an initial negative troponin finding. The aim of this study was to determine in post hoc analysis of a large regional medical center presenting clinical characteristics, treatment differences, and in-hospital and 6-month outcomes of first troponin-negative MI (FTNMI). In this study, 659 of 1,855 consecutive patients with non–ST-segment elevation MI (35.5%) were classified as having FTNMI. In-hospital cardiac catheterization rates were similar between the 2 groups (70.1% vs 71.5%, p = 0.53) In hospital, patients with FTNMI were less likely to receive statins (48.9% vs 59.9%, p <0.001). On discharge, patients with FTNMI were less likely to be on clopidogrel (53.1% vs 59.0%, p = 0.019) and statins (67.7% vs 75.2%, p <0.001). At 6-month follow-up, patients with FTNMI were less likely to be on clopidogrel (43.5% vs 55.2%, p = 0.01) In-hospital recurrent ischemia was 2 times as common in FTNMI (20.1% vs 11.5%, p <0.001). There were no differences, however, in congestive heart failure, cardiogenic shock, cardiac arrest, stroke, or death in hospital. At 6 months, patients with FTNMI were 2 times as likely to have had recurrent MI (12.0% vs 6.6%, p <0.001). Combined end points of death at 6 months, MI, stroke, and rehospitalization were higher for FTNMI (47.7% vs 40.9%, p = 0.017); however, this was due to higher rates of recurrent MI. In conclusion, patients with FTNMI received less aggressive pharmacotherapy and were 2 times as likely to have recurrent MI at 6 months. FTNMI is common and represents a clinical entity that should be treated more aggressively.


Use of cardiac troponin has become routine in early diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction (MI) and provides important prognostic information. Given the increasing use of non–ST-segment elevation MI (NSTEMI) risk models and point-of-care troponin testing in emergency department settings, we examined a subset of patients with NSTEMI from a large regional medical center with an initially negative troponin finding. Little is known about this population and we sought to describe differences in presenting characteristics, in-hospital management, and in-hospital and 6-month outcomes. We hypothesized that patients with first troponin-negative MI (FTNMI) would be less likely to receive early aggressive treatment and more likely to have worse outcomes because treatment strategies are often guided by laboratory testing.


Methods


The study cohort consisted of patients who presented or were transferred to the University of Michigan Medical Center (Ann Arbor, Michigan) from January 1999 to June 2006 and given the admission diagnosis of acute coronary syndrome. Based on discharge diagnosis, patients with STEMI and unstable angina were then excluded, leaving only patients with NSTEMI. Patients had to present or be transferred within 24 hours of symptom onset. Identified charts were reviewed by physicians for entry criteria. Inclusion into the study required symptoms consistent with acute coronary syndrome and increased cardiac biomarkers (creatinine kinase-MB >2 times upper limit of normal and/or troponin I >0.39 ng/mol for the University of Michigan Medical Center and 0.10 to 2.00 ng/mol for transferred patients). There was no intermediate range for troponin values. Clinical, demographic, treatment, and outcome data were abstracted from medical charts by trained abstractors. Data were collected on a 6-page standardized data form and then forwarded to a database service for dual data entry after review for face validity. Demographic variables included age and gender. Co-morbidities included previous heart disease including angina, congestive heart failure, MI, coronary artery bypass grafting, percutaneous coronary intervention, diabetes mellitus, smoking, hyperlipidemia, and hypertension. Electrocardiographic changes and initial laboratory data were recorded. Procedures and complications during acute coronary syndrome hospitalization were documented. These patients were then followed up by telephone or review of medical records approximately 6 months after discharge, at which point outcomes and medication adherence were noted. The protocol was approved by the institutional review board at the University of Michigan and informed consent was obtained as stipulated by the review board.


All patients with NSTEMI were categorized by FTNMI (n = 659) or first troponin-positive MI (FTNMI; n = 1,196). Univariate comparisons between groups were performed using Pearson chi-square-test or Fisher’s exact test for categorical variables where appropriate and Student’s t test for continuous variables. Multiple logistic regression modeling was performed to derive the independent association of clinical variables with in-hospital outcomes and outcomes at 6 months after discharge. In-hospital outcomes of interest included death, reinfarction, stroke, cardiogenic shock, pulmonary edema, cardiac arrest, atrial fibrillation/flutter, and composite of major adverse cardiac events (i.e., death, stroke, and reinfarction). Reinfarction was defined as re-increase of creatinine kinase-MB or troponin to above upper limits of normal and increase by ≥50% above the previous value. Stroke, embolic and/or hemorrhagic, was defined as onset of focal neurologic signs or symptoms, e.g., loss or slurring of speech, with confirmation by computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging. Recurrent ischemia was classified as additional symptoms occurring beyond the first 24 hours after presentation combined with electrocardiographic abnormalities and/or increase of cardiac enzyme >2 times upper limit of normal. Cardiogenic shock was defined as presence of pulmonary edema and hypoperfusion characterized by systolic blood pressure <80 mm Hg. We also compared rates of death, recurrent MI, unscheduled revascularization, stroke, and a composite of these at 6 months after discharge. SPSS 15 (SPSS, Inc., Chicago, Illinois) was used for all analyses.




Results


This study included 3,624 consecutive patients who presented with acute coronary syndrome, of whom 1,855 had a NSTEMI. In 659 of the 1,855 patients (35.5%), the first troponin result was negative but later became positive. In 968 of 1,704 patients (56.8%) with NSTEMI with the 2 measurements available, diagnosis was made by troponin increase with creatinine kinase-MB levels <2 times upper limit of normal. Patients with FTNMI were more likely to be men, have a history of transient ischemic attack, and have a history of congestive heart failure. Patients with FTNMI also had fewer T-wave inversions on initial electrocardiogram and a higher presenting mean diastolic blood pressure. Patients with FTNMI were more likely to be taking calcium channel blockers and less likely to be taking clopidogrel on hospital admission. No difference in time to hospital presentation was noted between the 2 groups ( Table 1 ).



Table 1

Baseline characteristics














































































































































































Variable FTNMI FTPMI p Value
Mean age (years) 64.9 65.5 0.387
Mean body mass index (kg/m 2 ) 29.0 29.4 0.436
Men 67.2% (443/659) 60.1% (719/1,196) 0.002
Medical history
Myocardial infarction 43.7% (288/659) 42.1% (504/1,196) 0.515
Percutaneous coronary intervention 26.4% (173/656) 26.6% (318/1,196) 0.92
Transient ischemic attack 14.0% (92/656) 10.9% (130/1,194) 0.047
Congestive heart failure 25.2% (166/658) 20.2% (241/1,194) 0.012
Coronary artery bypass grafting 23.6% (155/657) 21.6% (258/1,195) 0.322
Smoker ever 58.2% (383/658) 58.9% (701/1,191) 0.785
Diabetes mellitus 34.7% (228/657) 32.2% (384/1,194) 0.266
Hyperlipidemia 60.6% (397/655) 64.0% (764/1,193) 0.144
Hypertension 72.3% (474/656) 71.3% (850/1,192) 0.665
Systolic blood pressure (mean mm Hg) 143.50 140.48 0.056
Diastolic blood pressure (mean mm Hg) 79.34 77.10 0.038
Pulse (beats/min) 82.11 81.25 0.441
Killip class
I 79.1% (520/657) 82.6% (1,491/1,833) 0.071
II 12.8% (84/657) 11.2% (132/1,176) 0.32
III 7.8% (51/657) 6.0% (71/1,176) 0.155
Initial electrocardiogram
ST-segment depressions 10.2% (67/659) 10.7% (128/1,196) 0.719
T-wave inversions 9.1% (60/659) 13.9% (166/1,196) 0.003
Mean time to presentation (days) 0.167 0.298 0.217
Long-term medications
Aspirin 57.5% (341/593) 54.3% (603/1,111) 0.202
Clopidogrel 11.0% (65/593) 17.3% (193/1,111) <0.001
Calcium channel blocker 25.6% (152/593) 18.0% (200/1,111) <0.001
β Blocker 49.1% (291/593) 49.1% (596/1,111) 0.977
Angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor 35.8% (212/593) 37.9% (421/1,111) 0.383
Angiotensin receptor blocker 6.6% (39/593) 6.2% (69/1,111) 0.768
Nitrate 28.0% (166/593) 27.9% (310/1,111) 0.968
Statin 43.8% (260/593) 45.5% (506/1,111) 0.502


As presented in Table 2 , in-hospital cardiac catheterization rates were similar between the 2 groups and coronary artery bypass surgery was more common in patients with FTPMI. Coronary blood flow was significantly different between the 2 groups ( Table 2 ). Thrombolysis In Myocardial Infarction (TIMI) grade 0 to 1 flow was more common in patients with FTPMI and TIMI grade 2 flow was more common in those with FTNMI. No difference existed in mean percent stenosis of the culprit vessel, number of vessels affected, or final mean ejection fraction between the 2 groups.



Table 2

Hospital procedures and catheterization data

























































































FTNMI FTPMI p Value
Hospital procedures
Cardiac catheterization 70.1% (462/659) 71.5% (855/1,196) 0.53
Percutaneous coronary intervention 45.1 (297/659) 40.7% (487/1,196) 0.07
Coronary artery bypass graft surgery 6.4% (42/659) 10.5% (125/1,196) 0.003
Catheterization data
>50% stenosis
1 vessel 25.2% (104/412) 27.0% (212/785) 0.511
2 vessels 26.5% (109/412) 24.6% (193/785) 0.479
3 vessels 34.7% (143/412) 33.0% (259/785) 0.551
4 vessels 7.8% (32/412) 7.0% (55/785) 0.63
Culprit artery Thrombolysis In Myocardial Infarction grade flow
0–1 33.9% (37/109) 54.5% (140/257) <0.001
2 52.3% (57/109) 36.2% (93/257) 0.004
3 (normal) 13.8% (15/109) 9.3% (24/257) 0.21
Culprit artery percent stenosis 86.35% 87.72% 0.264
Mean final ejection fraction 50.80% 50.30% 0.602


Pharmacotherapy was different between the 2 groups during hospitalization, at discharge, and at 6 months ( Table 3 ). In-hospital medical treatment showed that patients with FTNMI were more likely to receive unfractionated heparin and less likely to receive statins. On discharge patients with FTNMI were less likely to be on clopidogrel and statins. At 6-month follow-up patients with FTNMI were less likely to be on clopidogrel.



Table 3

Medical therapy




























































































































Medical Treatment FTNMI FTPMI p Value
Early in hospital
Aspirin 94.1% (620/659) 93.6% (1,119/1,195) 0.706
β Blocker 85.0% (560/659) 82.8% (990/1,196) 0.221
Unfractionated heparin 84.5% (102/557) 79.0% (943/1,194) 0.004
Low-molecular-weight heparin 6.2% (41/658) 7.1% (85/1,193) 0.465
Statin 48.9% (322/659) 59.5% (712/1,196) <0.001
Discharge medications
Aspirin 87.3% (519/593) 90.3% (1,003/1,111) 0.063
Clopidogrel 53.1% (315/593) 59.0% (565/1,111) 0.019
Calcium channel blocker 19.7% (117/593) 16.4% (182/1,111) 0.083
β Blocker 83.0% (492/593) 83.6% (929/1,111) 0.731
Angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor 56.8% (337/593) 60.0% (667/1,111) 0.2
Angiotensin receptor blocker 5.9% (35/593) 5.3% (59/1,111) 0.61
Nitrate 46.9% (278/593) 48.7% (541/1,111) 0.475
Statin 67.6% (401/593) 75.2% (835/1,111) <0.001
6-month medications
Aspirin 85.2% (409/480) 88.3% (738/836) 0.109
Clopidogrel 43.5% (67/154) 55.2% (322/583) 0.01
Calcium channel blocker 20.8% (95/456) 18.3% (150/821) 0.265
β Blocker 83.6% (388/464) 80.9% (673/832) 0.221
Angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor 52.5% (243/463) 59.5% (493/828) 0.014
Angiotensin receptor blocker 21.6% (37/171) 11.2% (66/588) <0.001
Statin 73.7% (344/467) 75.6% (629/832) 0.439


In-hospital symptoms of recurrent ischemia were 2 times as common in patients with FTNMI ( Table 4 ). There were no differences, however, in congestive heart failure, cardiogenic shock, cardiac arrest, stroke, or death in hospital. In addition, time from onset of symptoms to hospital presentation and length of stay were similar between the 2 groups. At 6 months, patients with FTNMI were 2 times as likely to have had recurrent MI ( Table 5 ). The 2 groups did not differ in death, stroke, or cardiac rehospitalization at 6 months. Combined end point of death at 6 months, MI, stroke, and rehospitalization was higher for patients with FTNMI, but this was due to higher rates of recurrent MI.



Table 4

Hospital events












































FTNMI FTPMI p Value
Recurrent ischemia 20.1% (132/657) 11.5% (137/1,196) <0.001
Congestive heart failure 8.4% (55/655) 6.6% (79/1,195) 0.156
Cardiac shock 4.9% (32/655) 4.7% (56/1,196) 0.844
Reinfarction within 24 hours 2.6% (4/155) 3.7% (27/738) 0.505
Cardiac arrest 3.2% (21/657) 2.8% (33/1,195) 0.595
Stroke 0.9% (6/657) 0.6% (7/1,191) 0.423
Death in hospital 4.6% (30/656) 4.5% (53/1,190) 0.906

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Dec 22, 2016 | Posted by in CARDIOLOGY | Comments Off on Treatment and Outcomes of First Troponin-Negative Non–ST-Segment Elevation Myocardial Infarction

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access