Physician Qualifications in the Clinical Diagnostic Vascular Laboratory


Total number of accredited labs

1653

Total number of accredited sites

2736

Testing areas:

 Extracranial

1498 (90%)

 Intracranial

83 (5%)

 Venous

1197 (72%)

 Arterial

1187 (71%)

 Visceral

370 (22%)

 Screening

26 (1%)


Data courtesy of Ms. Marge Hutchisson, IAC



Why should we care if the vascular lab is accredited and the physician doing the interpretation is qualified? Quite simply, if a patient is sent to the vascular lab and receives a false-positive test, this may expose the patient to additional unnecessary testing or procedures with potential complications. On the other hand, a patient receiving a false-negative test may have a false sense of security, delay in diagnosis, and potentially an adverse clinical event. Unfortunately, this happens too frequently in current clinical practice. A typical example is that of a patient with an asymptomatic cervical bruit referred for a carotid duplex scan. A false-positive scan may lead to another more invasive test, such as a CT or cerebral angiogram. It is less likely but possible that this patient could be subjected to an unnecessary carotid endarterectomy based on this erroneous initial test. On the other hand, if the test is a false negative, and the patient has a critical stenosis, watchful waiting may lead to cerebrovascular symptoms, even a stroke. The sensitive issue about appropriate testing is being debated ad nauseam in the media with regard to screening mammography for women and the ideal age and frequency to be carried out. The American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) sponsored an initiative named Choosing Wisely to help patients and laymen understand the appropriateness of tests (www.​choosingwisely.​com).

With the proliferation of vascular labs and mobile units, many payors have begun to require that testing facilities be accredited. According to the IAC website, CMS requirements in most states stipulate that the lab and/or the technologist performing the test need to be credentialed in order to receive full reimbursement. Clearly, this is an important first step to ensure that vascular testing is done properly. The substandard testing in some unaccredited labs should be considered fraud and abuse, and invariably leads to repeat testing in an accredited lab, a waste in precious resources [7]. In response to the perceived overuse of diagnostic imaging, the US congress mandated major payment cuts for all diagnostic modalities in the Deficit Reduction Act of 2006; some tests were cut by 40% [8]. Furthermore, the most recent Healthcare Law passed in the USA in 2015, MACRA (Medicare Access and Children’s Health Insurance Program Reauthorization Act), aims to achieve better care, smarter spending, and healthier people, in part by tying a significant portion of reimbursement to quality (https://​www.​cms.​gov/​Medicare/​Quality-Initiatives-Patient-Assessment-Instruments/​Value-Based-Programs/​MACRA-MIPS-and-APMs/​MACRA-MIPS-and-APMs.​html).


Educational Background


Patients with vascular disorders will frequently be touched by multiple specialists from varying backgrounds (Fig. 2.1). Postgraduate education in vascular surgery and vascular medicine are two well-defined pathways to achieve Board certification . Successful completion of an accredited vascular surgery training program is a requisite to sit for the American Board of Surgery (ABS) Vascular Certificate . Similarly, training in an accredited Vascular Medicine program will lead to eligibility to sit for the Vascular Medicine Certificate of the American Board of Internal Medicine. The structured curricula in the latter specialties build on the essential elements listed below [911]. Other specialties, such as neurology and radiology, receive more focused instruction and training in their respective areas. Interventional Radiologists have broad training in invasive procedures, including angiography and other diagnostic modalities. Therefore, physicians from various backgrounds and training (e.g., neurology, radiology, vascular medicine, vascular surgery) may become qualified to interpret carotid duplex scans or transcranial Dopplers based on their training and area of expertise.

A60412_4_En_2_Fig1_HTML.gif


Fig. 2.1
Medical and surgical specialties interacting with a vascular patient


Suggested Curriculum for Physicians Interpreting in the Vascular Laboratory

Pathophysiology of vascular disease including arterial (atherosclerotic and nonatherosclerotic), venous, and lymphatic

Ultrasound physics, Doppler instruments, transducer technology

Basis of physiologic testing (ABI, PPG, APG)*

Duplex imaging of arteries, veins, vascular conduits, and soft tissues

Ultrasound and duplex diagnosis of:



  • Aortic aneurysms and other aortoiliac diseases


  • Imaging for aortic stent grafts


  • Renal and mesenteric arteries and veins


  • Renal and liver transplants


  • Portal venous system


  • Carotid arteries and structures in the neck


  • Lower extremity occlusive and aneurismal disease


  • Bypass grafts


  • Venous reflux testing


  • Arteriovenous access for dialysis

Statistical methods and understanding of false positive, negative, and accuracy

Advantages and limitations of vascular diagnostic modalities

*ABI ankle-brachial index, PPG photoplethysmography, APG air plethysmography



Physician Qualifications


The IAC explicitly states that a DVL is a “unit performing noninvasive vascular diagnostic testin g under the overall direction of a Medical Director” [5]. The intent is to place the overall responsibility and supervision for a DVL in the hands of a qualified physician who can then ensure that the lab is complying with accepted standards. The medical director should be (1) a legally qualified physician and (2) have one or more of the following: (a) completion of a residency or fellowship that includes appropriate clinical and didactic vascular laboratory experience with a defined number of studies interpreted, (b) self-study training through formal accredited postgraduate education and supervised vascular laboratory experience (preferably in accredited vascular laboratory under formally trained medical director) with interpretation of a defined number of cases, and (c) previous work in a vascular laboratory (preferably in accredited vascular laboratory under formally trained medical director) with interpretation of a defined number of cases [5]. The latter criteria also apply to the interpreting physician.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Dec 8, 2017 | Posted by in CARDIOLOGY | Comments Off on Physician Qualifications in the Clinical Diagnostic Vascular Laboratory

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access