Highlights
-
•
World first randomised control trial of a yoga intervention plus standard care compared to standard care alone in patients with atrial fibrillation.
-
•
Dual primary endpoints of time to AF recurrence and AF burden.
-
•
High intensity rhythm monitoring with ILRs or wearables.
-
•
Robust mechanistic endpoints: CPET, TTE, assessment autonomics.
ABSTRACT
Background
Lifestyle modification is a key pillar of atrial fibrillation (AF) management. Yoga has beneficial effects on cardiovascular health and has shown promise as an intervention in AF. However, randomized data are absent.
Objectives
To determine the effect of regular yoga on AF episodes and AF burden in people with paroxysmal or persistent AF over a 12-month period.
Methods
This is a randomized control trial of a yoga program in addition to standard care, compared to standard care alone in people with paroxysmal or persistent AF undergoing a rhythm control management strategy. 222 participants will be randomized 1:1 to the yoga intervention or control. Yoga will be conducted in studio and online with a target of at least 3 classes/week. Controls will be instructed to exercise for at least 150 minutes/week. Rhythm monitoring will be with implantable loop recorder, or ECG capable smartwatch with AF detection and twice daily ECGs. Autonomic metrics will be assessed in the laboratory by HRV, blood pressure variability and direct recordings of muscle sympathetic nerve activity. Following a 3-month training period, the dual primary endpoints of AF recurrence (time to recurrence, as defined by any sustained atrial tachyarrhythmia lasting >1 hour) and AF burden will be determined at 12 months.
Conclusions
This study aims to determine the impact of yoga on AF recurrence and burden in people with paroxysmal and persistent AF. Yoga may provide an effective noninvasive, nonpharmacologic lifestyle strategy in the management of AF.
Trial Registration
The trial was preregistered with the Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry (ACTRN12624000264583).
Background
Atrial fibrillation (AF) is an epidemic of cardiovascular disease, responsible for an increase in risk of stroke and heart failure and a doubling of mortality. A strategy of rhythm control is increasingly recommended over rate control for most patients due to significant reductions in major cardiovascular outcomes, including mortality. , However, there is a paucity of new antiarrhythmic drugs (AAD), and current drugs have limited efficacy and may not be well tolerated. Catheter ablation has been shown to be more effective than antiarrhythmic drugs in randomized controlled trials, but is costly, invasive, may need to be repeated, and is only performed in a minority of patients. Additionally, catheter ablation is less effective in patients with persistent AF. Therefore, modifiable lifestyle factors are now recognized as a key pillar in AF management and should be implemented regardless of whether ablation is undertaken. Alcohol reduction, exercise, and weight loss have been demonstrated to reduce AF and consequently the need for medication and ablation.
Yoga is a mind-body practice, popular, and available globally. Yoga incorporates physical postures to improve balance and flexibility, with meditation and structured breathing to reduce psychological stress and enhance relaxation. Yoga has direct autonomic effects, together with reductions in heart rate (HR), blood pressure (BP), and psychological stress. ,, A nonrandomized crossover study reported 3 months of near daily yoga significantly reduced AF episodes and improved QoL in 49 patients, however randomized studies are lacking. Therefore, we aim to perform a multicenter, randomized control trial to determine the impact of yoga in addition to usual care in patients with symptomatic AF undergoing a rhythm control management strategy.
Methods
The primary hypothesis is that participation in regular yoga over a 12-month period will result in a reduction in time to recurrent AF and AF burden. Patients with AF undergoing rhythm control will be recruited from major Victorian Hospitals (The Alfred, Cabrini Malvern), cardiology practices and the Baker Heart and Diabetes Research Institute. The trial has been granted ethical approval by the Alfred Hospital Human Ethics and Research Committee (Melbourne, Australia). The trial was preregistered with the Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry (ACTRN12624000264583).
Inclusion criteria
-
1.
Age: 18 to 80 years
-
2.
Persons with symptomatic paroxysmal AF (PAF) or persistent AF (PsAF) undertaking a rhythm control strategy
-
○
Symptomatic AF is defined a history of any symptoms when in AF including palpitations, shortness of breath, chest pain/discomfort, dizziness/light-headedness, fatigue or decreased exercise tolerance
-
○
-
3.
Episode of documented AF within the past 3 months
-
4.
Willingness and ability to given written informed consent and comply with the study protocol
-
5.
Physical ability to undertake Yoga and willing to commit to regular practice for 12 months
Exclusion criteria
-
1.
Regular yoga practice
-
2.
Permanent AF
-
3.
AF ablation in the past 6 months, or planned AF ablation in the coming 6 months
-
4.
Severe valvular dysfunction
-
5.
Acute myocardial infarction or cardiac surgery in preceding 6 months
-
6.
Uncontrolled thyroid disease, autoimmune or systemic inflammatory disease
-
7.
Dementia, cognitive impairment or lack of English language ability to a degree that would impair ability to understand instructions and participate in yoga classes
-
8.
Advanced malignancy or other medical condition resulting in life expectancy <12 months
-
9.
Unwilling to undergo loop recorder implantation and inability/unwillingness to use a smartwatch or wearable
Study protocol
Baseline investigations
All potential participants will be invited to undertake 3 prerecorded online beginner flow yoga classes to be completed within 2 weeks. This screening step is to ensure a willingness and physical ability to partake in yoga.
Next, participants will attend an in-person appointment, during which the following baseline investigations are completed ( Figure 1 ):
-
1.
Implantable loop recorder (ILR) inserted, or smartwatch provided
-
2.
ECG
-
3.
HR and BP measurement (the average of 3 BP measurements with the participant sitting quietly after resting for 5 minutes )
-
4.
echocardiogram (TTE)
-
5.
Cardiopulmonary exercise test (CPET)
-
6.
Hba1c and cholesterol prolife
-
7.
Quality of life (QoL) questionnaires (Atrial fibrillation Effect on Quality-of-life (AFEQT), hospital anxiety and depression scale (HADS), 36 item short form survey (SF-36))
-
8.
Autonomic assessment: 10-minute recording of heart rate variability (HRV) and blood pressure variability (BPV)
-
9.
Randomization
Flow chart showing trial investigations and follow up.
Autonomic assessment
Participants will undergo assessment of HRV and BPV at baseline. HR and BP will be measured continuously for 10 minutes at rest. ECG will be recorded with standard chest electrodes and noninvasive BP will be recorded continuously from cuffs on the fingers (Nova, Finapres Medical Systems, The Netherlands). Respiration will be recorded via a strain gauge transducer around the lower chest. Time and frequency domain analysis of HRV and BPV will be performed.
HRV will also be assessed throughout the study period using data from the participants rhythm monitoring device. Only measurements during periods of sinus rhythm will be included in analysis. In those with loop recorders HRV is available for each 24-hour period, presented as the SDANN (standard deviation of the average normal normal-to-normal RR (NN) intervals for each 5-minute segment over a 24-hour period ). In those with smartwatches, pulse rate variability is measured via Photoplethysmography (PPG) and presented as SDNN (standard deviation of all normal RR (NN) intervals during a 24‐hour period ). HRV measured by wearable devices have been previously validated. ,
HR Recovery, a measure of parasympathetic reactivation after exercise, will be assessed at baseline and 12 months on CPET.
Microneurography
A subgroup of 40 participants (20 participants from each group) will undergo microneurography to measure muscle nerve sympathetic activity (MSNA). At the time of enrolment all participants will be invited to undertake this additional testing until the required 40 participants have been recruited.
MNSA provides real time assessment of sympathetic outflow to the skeletal muscle. It involves insertion of a tungsten microelectrode into the peroneal nerve while delivering weak electrical stimulation through the microelectrode, until muscle twitches are evoked at 20 uA. The microelectrode tip is manipulated until spontaneous bursts of MSNA with clear cardiac rhythmicity are encountered. Neural activity will be amplified, filtered (bandpass 0.3-5.0 kHz) using a low noise headstage (NeuroAmpEX, ADInstruments, Sydney, Australia) and acquired (20 kHz sampling) using a computer-based data acquisition and analysis system (LabChart 7, PowerLab; ADInstruments). Spontaneous sympathetic baroreflex sensitivity will be estimated from the changes in MSNA to changes in diastolic pressure (slope of relationship between MSNA and diastolic BP). Spontaneous cardiovagal baroreflex sensitivity will be estimated by changes in HR to changes in systolic pressure.
Microneurography is time consuming, taking up to 3 hours per participant, and hence it is not feasible to perform this on all participants from a logistical perspective. Other autonomic assessments (HRV and BPV) will be collected in all.
Randomisation
Participants will be allocated 1:1 to yoga or control group by block randomization. Stratification by AF type (paroxysmal or persistent) and monitoring strategy (continuous monitoring from a cardiac device or monitoring from smart watch/wearable) has been included to ensure these variables are balanced between the groups. Computer generated randomization will be completed using the REDCap (Vanderbilt University, Tennessee) database hosted by Alfred Health. Due to the nature of the intervention, the participants cannot be blinded to group allocation. The study will be single blinded with investigators involved in interpretation of the primary endpoint blinded to study group allocation.
Intervention
Yoga group
Participants randomized to yoga will be asked to undertake at least 3, 45 to 60-minute yoga sessions per week for 12 months. Classes will be undertaken at a local yoga studio chosen by the participant and study investigators; all classes will be taught by qualified yoga teachers. The cost of the yoga classes is supported by Grant funding. Classes can be undertaken in person or online, with a preference for in person classes where possible. Yoga classes will involve participants performing a series of physical postures with coordinated controlled breathing and meditation (see figure 2 ). Given a wide variety of yoga techniques, the flow yoga style will be encouraged (eg, Hatha, Vinyasa, Iyengar). Study coordinators and qualified, experienced yoga teachers affiliated with the study (MS/TM) ensure that classes are initially tailored to the beginner level, with in studio instruction on achieving appropriate techniques before progressing to more challenging postures. Participants in the yoga arm will be encouraged to continue their usual forms of physical activity in addition to yoga. While in-person classes are preferred, participants are provided with access to live online classes weekly (delivered by MS), a list of online prerecorded yoga classes, and any online yoga classes run by the yoga studio they attend, providing them with alternatives if they are unable to attend classes in person.
Overview of the key components of yoga and the benefits of regular yoga practice.
Control group
The control group will receive standard care as directed by their treating physician. Participants in this group will receive general advice from study investigators regarding the importance of regular physical activity, they will not be provided with a structured or supervised exercise program. Recommendations for physical activity will be based on the American Heart Association Guidelines. , Participants will be provided with verbal and written information explaining recommendations for physical activity, and practical advice on how to safely commence regular physical activity and achieve study goals. Participants will be advised they should be undertaking at least 150 minutes per week of moderate-intensity aerobic activity, or 75 minutes per week of vigorous aerobic activity, or a combination of both. Additionally, moderate- to high-intensity muscle-strengthening activity should be undertaken at least twice a week. Participants not meeting these targets are advised to increase amount and intensity of activity over time. They will also be counselled on the importance of flexibility training and sitting less. Definitions of activities which fulfil the criteria for moderate and intense activity, and examples of aerobic and strengthening activities will be provided.
Participants will continue with medication, other risk factor modification, including weight loss and alcohol minimization, as directed by their treating physician, who is blinded to study group assignment. Participants will be told not to inform the treating doctors of their study group randomization. All participants are required to provide a weekly diary outlining the frequency and duration of all physical activity including yoga participation. The study investigators will then calculate the metabolic equivalents (METS) for these activities.
To ensure the ease and accuracy of diaries, participants are provided with a range of options for recording exercise including apps, excel spreadsheet or paper-based diaries, depending on preference. Attendance will be confirmed with yoga studios and participants who fail to send diaries will be followed up by research nurses via phone or email. In participants with ILRs active minutes per day, which is derived from the device rate response accelerometer, will be recorded. In participants using smartwatches data such as step count will be recorded. Additionally, participants will be encouraged to track their workouts using the watch including type of activity and start/stop times.
Follow up
Participants will be followed up for a minimum of 12 months. Study visits will occur at 3,6,9, and 12 months.
At 3, 6, and 9 month visits the following information will be collected via phone:
-
1.
Changes to AF management including medication, cardioversion or ablation
-
2.
AF symptoms
-
3.
Healthcare utilization (hospital admissions, including elective admission, emergency department attendance, general practitioner, cardiologist and other specialist appointments)
-
4.
BP recorded from a home monitor, or at doctor’s office/pharmacy. Participants will be asked to perform 3 measurements while sitting quietly after resting for 5 minutes and the average will be used.
-
5.
Review of exercise and yoga diaries
The final 12-month study visit will be conducted in person and includes the 3 monthly assessments as well as repeating all baseline investigations.
Rhythm monitoring
The preferred rhythm monitoring strategy is an ILR (Medtronic LINQ II), which will be inserted at the baseline visit. Where a pre-existing dual chamber pacemaker, defibrillator or ILR is present this will be utilized. Participants unwilling to undergo implantation of an ILR will be provided with an ECG capable smartwatch, this strategy has been chosen to allow otherwise eligible and motivated patients to still participate in the trial . A smartwatch compatible with the participants mobile device will be provided. Participants who already own a smart watch with ECG capabilities may use this. Participants will be required to always wear their smartwatch, except when charging and provide twice daily ECGs, plus additional ECGs if experiencing symptoms. Finally, participants not willing/able to have an ILR implanted, or use a smartwatch, will be provided with a Kardia Mobile (Alivecor, USA) ECG monitoring device.
ILRs will be set up on a remote monitoring system (Medtronic MyCareLink Heart Mobile) with transmissions sent to a dedicated study account. For participants with pre-existing devices, remote monitoring history and any device clinic reviews during the study period will be requested from the treating physician. Additionally, the device will be interrogated at baseline and at the final 12-month study visits.
Participants with a smartwatch will record a 30 second, single lead ECG twice daily and take additional recordings at the onset/offset of any symptoms suggestive of arrhythmia. The rhythm strips will be sent to a dedicated study email at the Alfred Hospital (Melbourne, Australia) and reviewed regularly by research clinicians. Rhythm strips adjudicated as sinus rhythm by the device will not undergo additional review. All ECGs labelled as AF or inconclusive by the device will be reviewed and adjudicated by 2 cardiologists blinded to study group allocation.
Calculation of AF burden
AF burden quantification will be performed using the following methods:
-
1.
Implantable cardiac device—the AF burden data will be derived from transmitted data on remote monitoring networks and/or data from device interrogation during follow up visits.
-
2.
Smart watch or Kardia Mobile device—the time of the recorded AF ECG will be taken as the onset of the episode, with the next recorded sinus rhythm taken as the offset. The duration of all episodes combined will then be expressed as a percentage of a predefined monitoring period (ie, 0-3 months, 3-6 months, 6-9 months, 9-12 months) to derive the burden for that period.
-
3.
Any other sources of rhythm documentation such as ambulatory or inpatient care will be included.
Study endpoints
Primary endpoint
The dual primary endpoints are;
-
1.
AF recurrence: time to recurrence, as defined by any sustained atrial arrhythmia lasting >60 minutes after an initial 12-week blanking period, and
-
2.
AF burden: commencing after an initial 12-week blanking period and calculated at 12 months follow up.
A 12- week “blanking” or introductory period has been arbitrarily defined to allow time for participants to learn basic yoga principles and gain a level of competence in performing yoga postures, breathing and meditation, before the impact on the endpoints is assessed.
Secondary endpoints
-
1.
A prespecified analysis of the endpoint events (time to recurrence and AF burden) will be performed in the subgroup with continuous monitoring from an implanted cardiac device.
-
2.
Clinical success defined as freedom from documented symptomatic atrial arrhythmia recurrence (episodes >1 hour)
-
3.
QoL and mental health questionnaires : AFEQT, HADS and SF-36
-
4.
AF related and total healthcare utilization
-
5.
Escalation in AF management defined as change in antiarrhythmic medication or dose increase, cardioversion, or catheter ablation
-
6.
Changes in HRV and BPV
-
•
Time and frequency domain analysis of HRV and BP from 10-minute recording from baseline and 12 months
-
•
24-hour HRV from ILR or smartwatch collected throughout the study period (HRV from periods of AF will not be utilized).
-
○
ILR: Daily HRV available via cardiac compass, weekly average will then be calculated
-
○
Smartwatch: weekly average HRV recorded
-
○
-
•
-
7.
Change in cardiorespiratory fitness as assessed by CEPT
-
8.
Change in resting HR and BP
-
9.
Average daytime and nighttime HR in sinus rhythm as recorded by ILR
-
10.
Change in BMI
-
11.
Change in left atrial size/volume as assessed by echocardiogram
-
12.
Reduction in MSNA in a subgroup of 40 participants
Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel
Full access? Get Clinical Tree