The Critically Ill Female Patient


Study

Study type

Aim

Main findings

Dates

Patients

Additional findings

Romo et al. [1]

Retrospective analysis mixed medical and surgical ICU

Evaluate difference in mortality between genders and between medical and surgical ICUs

Women had a higher mortality than men

1983

4420 admissions

Worse outcome especially in women >50 years

1995 (2 × 12 month periods studied)

−1587 female

−2833 male

−15% vs. 13%; OR 1.18 (95% CI 1.02–1.38; P < 0.05)

There is an interaction with gender with length of ICU stay—the difference in outcome less apparent after longer LOS OR of 1.54 (95% CI, 1.25–1.89) overall and an OR of 0.95 (95% CI, 0.92–0.98) for each day of increase in LOS

Belgian ICUs

Worse survival in women with cardiovascular diseases

−23% vs. 12%; OR, 2.07; (95% CI 1.50–2.87; P < 0.001)

Sathianathan et al. [2]

Retrospective single centre study: Australian ICU

Identify factors associated with survival on comatose survivors of arrest

Male gender improved survival to hospital discharge

20 years 1993–2012

582 patients

Median ICU LOS 3 days and hospital LOS 5

62% male

Shockable rhythm and shorter time to ROSC associated with survival to discharge

Samuelsson et al. [3]

Observational study—Registry date (multicentre)

? women of premenopausal age have better outcome

No survival advantage in pre-menopausal women

4 years 2008–2012

127,254 episodes

Presumed menopause at median age 45 years—arbitrary cut-off

57% male

No difference in 30 day mortality in women whether <45> years

43% female

Swedish ICU
 
Better outcome in men >45 years

Morrison et al. [4]

Registry data Observational study

To study the relationship between gender and outcomes in non traumatic out of hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA)

Lower survival in women

Dec 2005–May 2007

14,690 patients

Cohort to study effect of female reproductive hormones

unadjusted OR 0.69, 95% CI: 0.60, 0.77

36.4% women

64.2% men

Women more likely to achieve ROSC pre-hospital

North American and Canadian ICUs

With adjustment for Utstein predictors → women 15–45 years better survival to discharge (OR 1.66–95% CI 1.04–2.64)

Tao et al. [5]

Meta analysis

Influence of sex on outcomes in trauma patients

Protective effect of female gender on outcomes (mortality, LOS and fatal complications)

Upto 2013

Pooled data—19 studies 100,566 men 39,762 women
 
Mahmood et al. [6]

Observational retrospective study in American ICUs

Assess the association of gender with

Overall Survival advantage for younger women

Jan 2004–December 2008

261,255 pts

ICU mortality 7.2% men and 7.9% women

144,254 men (55.2%)

Pts <50 years—women had reduced ICU mortality vs. men: OR 0.83 (95% CI 0.79–0.91)—adjusted for physiology score, ethnicity, co-morbid conditions, pre-ICU LOS, pre-ICU location and hospital teaching status

117,001women (44.8%)

Worse outcome women post-CABG

1. ICU mortality

2. Active therapies

Better outcome after COPD

3. Outcomes in disease subgroups

No difference amongst >50 years

No difference in sepsis, ACS, trauma

Pietropaoli et al. [7]

Retrospective database cohort

Hypothesis—hospital mortality is higher in men compared to women with sepsis or septic shock requiring ICU

Hospital mortality higher in women

2003–2006

18,757 pts

Disparity in delivery and processes of care

10,055 men (54%)

Multi centre—98 ICUs in 71 US hospitals and four Canadian/Brazilian units

OR = 1.11 95% CI 1.04–1.19 p = 0.002

8702 women (46%)

Equal number of organ dysfunction between genders

No difference if >or< 50 years

Quenot et al. [8]

Prospective multicentre

Evaluate prognostic factors associated with 28 days mortality in septic shock

Same mortality men and women

Nov 2009–March 2011

1495 shocked
 
63.9% male

36.1% female

French units

Raine et al. [9]

ICNARC registry data

Comparison of case mix and outcomes of male and female patients admitted to ICUs

No difference in admission and mortality in cardiac arrhythmia, COPD, asthma, self poisoning, seizures. Some inequity in AMI and neurological bleeding

3 years

46,587

Demonstration of horizontal and vertical inequity in ICU

91 UK units

Vincent et al. [10]

Multi centre observational cohort

To define the incidence and characteristics of critically ill patients in Europe

Female gender independent risk factor for mortality

2 weeks

3147 patients

Numerous additional substudies published

May 2002

198 European ICUs


CU intensive care unit, LOS length of stay, APACHE acute physiology and chronic health evaluation, CABG coronary artery bypass graft, COPD chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, ACS acute coronary syndrome, ARDS adult respiratory distress syndrome, ROSC return of spontaneous circulation





Physical and Pharmacological Differences


Physical differences between male and female patients largely do not affect their management in the cardiac intensive care unit except relating to physical size. Other than basic critical care considerations regarding airway and ventilatory management (endotracheal tube/tracheostomy size, ideal body weight tidal volumes) and drug dosage, there is little that is not encompassed in general critical care management, however some areas warrant specific consideration. First, women who meet nutritional goals have a lower hazard ratio of dying on the intensive care compared with men, but this benefit is lost if they meet their energy target but fail to reach their protein target (possibly due to the smaller total protein stores in women). Second, the anatomical and physiological differences between genders (including body weight, composition, GI motility, liver metabolism and glomerular filtration rate) significantly alter pharmacokinetics and dynamics of drugs, including absorption, distribution, metabolism and elimination. Women are more susceptible to the effects of neuromuscular blockade, opioid receptor agonists, and beta adrenergic agents, as well as having a variable but attenuated response to pressor agents under conditions of stress. The potential response to beta adrenergic agents on cardiovascular function should also be carefully considered prior to institution of therapy. In particular, elderly female patients with basal septal hypertrophy may respond to dobutamine by developing worsening abnormalities of diastolic dysfunction and significantly increasing left-ventricular outflow tract obstruction. The condition should be suspected in case of deteriorating cardiac output in the presence of escalating inotropic support, and is readily confirmed using echocardiography. Treatment comprises cessation of beta adrenergic agents, volume and pressor resuscitation, and timely re-introduction of beta blocking agents (where right ventricular function allows).

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Oct 26, 2017 | Posted by in CARDIOLOGY | Comments Off on The Critically Ill Female Patient

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access