CME
Recognizing Normal, Abnormal, and Benign Nonepileptiform Electroencephalographic Activity and Patterns in Polysomnographic Recordings
Keywords
• Electroencephalogram • Variants • Nonepileptiform • Epileptiform
An EEG is abnormal if it contains: (1) epileptiform activity or electrographic seizure patterns; (2) slow waves inappropriate to the state of wake/sleep; (3) amplitude abnormalities; or (4) certain patterns resembling normal activity but deviating from it in frequency, reactivity, distribution, or other features.1 Abnormalities in EEG need to be distinguished from normal patterns, benign variants, and artifacts.
Deviations from normal EEG patterns
The Dominant Posterior Alpha Rhythm
Interpretation of an EEG (or scoring an epoch of sleep in a PSG) begins by analyzing whether a DPR is present, bilateral, symmetric, and within the expected normal frequency range for age and state. The DPR (also called the dominant alpha rhythm or the alpha rhythm) is probably the most important EEG pattern and rhythm. The alpha rhythm is often of highest amplitude over the occipital, posterior temporal, and parietal scalp regions. In one-third of healthy adults, the alpha rhythm extends into the temporal and central regions, which results in the DPR equally seen in the frontal, central, and occipital channels linked to the mastoid references when recording EEG during a routine PSG (Fig. 1).
The alpha rhythm is usually best seen with eyes closed during periods of physical relaxation and relative mental inactivity; it attenuates or is blocked by eye opening and attention, especially visual and mental effort (Fig. 2). This attribute is called reactivity of the alpha rhythm, and can vary from complete suppression of the activity to varying degrees of attenuation with voltage reduction. Reactivity of the DPR may be transient, or appear and then fade with continued eye closure. Some have a DPR that is nonreactive; absent reactivity of an alpha rhythm is only abnormal if it is distinctly asymmetric.
The frequency of the DPR in normal adults ranges from 8 Hz to 13 Hz or more. Most normal adults and adolescents have an alpha rhythm between 9 and 11 Hz, and only 5% have a DPR of 11.5 Hz or more.2 The mean DPR in 500 normal adult subjects was 10.2 ± 0.9 Hz, 10.5 Hz in those adults younger than age 24 years, and 10.4 Hz in those 24 to 47 years old.3 The DPR remains greater than 8.5 Hz even in healthy octogenarians.
In approximately 25% of normal adults, the alpha rhythm is poorly visualized, with 6% to 7% of normal adults demonstrating voltages of less than 15 Hz.4 Because of this, the bilateral absence of a DPR is not considered abnormal. The frequency of alpha rhythm is only measured when the patient is awake and not drowsy because it decreases by 1 to 2 Hz with drowsiness. In the baseline calibration period of a PSG, the DPR is best measured and assessed during periods of eye opening and closure.
DPRs first appear in infants 3 to 4 months’ term as irregular, relatively high-amplitude (50–100 μV or greater), reactive 3.5- to 4.5-Hz activity over the occipital regions. Many infants achieve 5 to 6 Hz by 5 to 6 months of age, 70% have 5- to 6-Hz alpha-like activity by 12 months’ term, and 82% have a mean occipital frequency of 8 Hz (range 7.5–9.5 Hz) by 36 months of age.5 Most children have a 9- to 11-Hz posterior alpha rhythm by 8 years of age, and normal adult occipital alpha frequencies are typically reached by 13 years. The mean posterior alpha frequency is 9 Hz in 65% of the 9-year-olds and 10 Hz in 65% of normal children by age 15.
Be advised that a young child does not close the eyes until drowsy, so the frequency of the posterior rhythm when a young child’s eyes spontaneously close often represents drowsiness. As seen in adults, during drowsiness the DPR is often 1 to 2 Hz slower than the child’s actual DPR. Reactivity of the DPR to passive eye closure can be first seen as early as 3 months of age, and is usually first present by 5 to 6 months.6,7
Abnormalities of the DPR
Electroencephalographers use the term slowed background for a waking posterior alpha rhythm that is too slow for age and state. A DPR that never exceeds 8 Hz in an awake adult is abnormal because a DPR of less than 8 Hz is seen in less than 1% of normal adult subjects at any age.1,8 The absolute lower limits of abnormal for the frequency of the DPR are: less than 5 Hz at age 1, less than 6 Hz at age 3, less than 7 Hz at age 5, and less than 8 Hz at age 8 years.9
A unilateral decrease in the frequency of the DPR is considered abnormal if there is a consistent left-right difference of greater than 0.5 Hz, but differences of less than 1 Hz are difficult to appreciate without signal analysis methods such as spectral analysis.1 The DPR is usually of higher amplitude on the right. A DPR with an amplitude that is 50% or more lower on the left compared with the right, or 35% or more on the right compared with the left, may be abnormal. Voltage asymmetries are best measured using referential EEG derivations (eg, O1-M2 and O2-M1). Asymmetries in the DPR amplitude when not accompanied by other EEG abnormalities should be interpreted with caution because they can occur in healthy individuals. Asymmetries in the DPR voltage need to recognized by the technologist while recording, and should prompt confirmation that the interelectrode distances are equal for the locations of homologous electrodes. If the distance between O1-M2 is less than O2-M1, the amplitude of O1-M2 may appear falsely lower.
Clinical Significance of Abnormalities in the DPR
A unilateral slowed or absent DPR can be seen with: (1) ipsilateral damage to the occipital cortex (ie, stroke, contusion, and tumor); (2) ipsilateral damage to thalamus; (3) transient ischemic attacks; (4) milder head injuries; and (5) following a seizure or migraine. Fig. 3 shows a significantly slower and poorly sustained DPR on the left. Unilateral failure of the DPR to attenuate (react) with eye opening or mental concentration is called the Bancaud phenomenon, and is seen with ipsilateral temporal or parietal cortical lesions such as tumors or infarcts.10 However, asymmetries in frequencies of the posterior rhythm occasionally are falsely lateralizing when the dominant generator of the posterior rhythm involves the medial surface of one cerebral hemisphere and projects contralaterally.
Normal and Abnormal Beta Activity
Beta activity are EEG frequencies greater than 13 Hz. Beta activity is most often seen over the frontal and central scalp regions, usually at a frequency of 18 to 25 Hz, less often at 14 to 16 Hz, and rarely at 35 Hz. Beta activity may become more prominent or accentuated by mental, lingual, or cognitive efforts. Beta activity typically has a voltage of 5 to 20 μV. The voltage of beta activity in 98% of adults is less than 20 μV, and beta voltages greater than 25 μV are considered abnormal.8
Excessive prominent augmentation of 15- to 25-Hz beta activity during wakefulness and drowsiness in an older child or an adult is most often the result of a medication effect, particularly seen with benzodiazepines and barbiturates.11 Benzodiazepines, barbiturates, and chloral hydrate are potent activators of beta activity, often increasing beta activity in the 14- to 16-Hz bandwidth. Increased theta activity may accompany excessive beta activity in some cases.
Central nervous system stimulants such as methylphenidate, amphetamines, cocaine, tricyclic antidepressants, and levothyroxine also increase beta activity, but such activity is often low in voltage.12 Withdrawal from alcohol or barbiturates may produce a similar low-voltage EEG with beta activity.12,13 The beta-inducing effects of medications on the EEG are more pronounced in children compared with adults, and in acute rather than chronic use.12 Fig. 4 shows increased beta activity on a PSG, caused by clonazepam.
Beta activity is usually symmetric. Persistently reduced voltages of beta activity greater than 50% suggest a cortical gray abnormality within the lower amplitude hemisphere. Lesser intermittent voltage asymmetries may simply reflect normal physiologic skull asymmetries.8 A persistent focal suppression or attenuation of beta activity over a scalp region or hemisphere is a reliable localizing sign, and a hallmark of a structural lesion involving the underlying cerebral cortex or from an extradural fluid collection (such as a subdural hematoma). Focal attenuation of faster activities on the side of the lesion is most commonly associated with occlusive vascular disease.14
A marked focal increase in beta activity is most often caused by an underlying skull defect (most often a craniotomy or burr hole). Known as a breach rhythm, this pattern is characterized by sharply contoured waveforms with beta activity that is often threefold higher than that seen over other scalp regions (Fig. 5).15 Misidentifying the sharply contoured waveforms evident in the region of the breach rhythm because of interictal epileptiform discharges (IEDs) is a common perilous pitfall in EEG interpretation.16 The defect in the skull (most often a craniotomy, burr hole, or fracture) creates a low-resistance pathway for EEG currents, resulting in a localized increase in beta activity that is maximal near the margins of the skull defect. The amplitude of underlying theta and alpha activity is similarly enhanced through the defect, and this leads to the sharply contoured waveforms being misidentified as discharges.17 Of note, focal delta slowing over a skull defect is not caused by the skull defect, but reflects the acute or chronic underlying focal structural lesion. Asymmetric eye movements can be seen in patients with frontal skull defects. On rare occasions, beta activity is increased on the scalp region overlying a brain tumor or a focal cortical dysplastic lesion.14
Abnormalities in the Polysomnographic Markers of Sleep
Abnormalities of the distinctive PSG markers of sleep, such as sleep spindles and vertex waves, may be seen in PSG recording using standard and expanded EEG montages. Sleep spindles first appear in NREM 2, and may persist in early NREM 3 sleep. Sleep spindles most often occur at a frequency of 12 to 14 Hz (but range from 10 to 16 Hz), and recur at a frequency of 3 to 6 bursts per minute in stable undisturbed NREM 2 sleep. Sleep spindles first appear 3 to 4 weeks’ term (43–44 weeks conceptional age) over the midline central (vertex, Cz) region. The absence of sleep spindles by 3 months’ term is considered abnormal. At 3 and 6 months’ term, 50% of sleep spindles are synchronous, shifting at times from side to side. Sleep spindles are synchronous by 12 months in 70% of cases. By age 2 years, sleep spindles appear synchronously over both hemispheres and are approximately symmetric.18
The unilateral absence, decreased amplitude, or decreased frequency of sleep spindles is associated with an underlying ipsilateral pathologic condition, which can be found within the cortex or along the thalamocortical axis.19 Fig. 6 shows an example of asymmetric sleep spindles caused by a unilateral thalamic stroke. Sleep-spindle activity may be influenced by various hypnotic-sedative drugs.20 Benzodiazepines and barbiturates also increase sleep-spindle activity. Bilateral prolonged spindles have been seen in recordings of patients with chronic and/or excessive benzodiazepines and barbiturate use.20 An uncommon pattern of almost continuous sleep spindles during NREM 2 (called extreme spindles) has been observed in individuals with severe intellectual disability.21,22