Epidemiology
Bochdalek hernias are usually diagnosed in neonates whereas Morgagni hernias tend to be found in adults. Bochdalek diaphragmatic hernias occur in approximately 1:2000 children. Morgagni hernias occur much less frequently than Bochdalek hernias, and account for only 5 percent of all congenital diaphragmatic hernias. Acquired sliding (type I) hiatal hernias may be found in up to 15 percent of the population, and account for 95 percent of acquired diaphragmatic defects. The remaining 5 percent of acquired diaphragmatic hernias are composed primarily of paraesophageal (type II) hernias. Acquired diaphragmatic hernias are often diagnosed in patients with risk factors for increased intra-abdominal pressures. Diaphragmatic paralysis most commonly occurs following cardiac surgery procedures, with incidences ranging from less than 1 percent to approximately 10 percent. Most diaphragmatic tumors are metastatic in nature, and primary tumors of the diaphragm are quite rare.
Pathophysiology
In neonates, Bochdalek hernias result in abdominal viscera assuming an intrathoracic position, typically into the left hemithorax. This displacement often impairs growth of the ipsilateral lung, causes mediastinal deviation to the contralateral chest, pulmonary compromise, and pulmonary hypertension. Morgagni hernias also result in abdominal viscera herniation into the chest; however, presenting symptoms more often are related to bowel obstruction. Sliding hiatal (type I) hernias are defined as a supradiaphragmatic displacement of the gastroesophageal (GE) junction. The abnormal anatomy impairs lower esophageal sphincter (LES) function and results in reflux symptoms. Paraesophageal (type II) hernias occur when the gastric fundus assumes a supradiaphragmatic position, whereas the GE junctions remain in its normal anatomical location. Diaphragmatic paralysis may result from any abnormality along the neuromuscular axis. Diaphragmatic tumors are most commonly the result of metastatic tumors originating in surrounding organs.
Clinical features
In extreme circumstances, Bochdalek hernia may result in early respiratory compromise requiring prompt surgical interventions or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO). Those diagnosed with Morgagni hernia often present with abdominal symptoms and discomfort. The abnormal anatomy associated with sliding (type I) hiatal hernias impair LES function, thus producing reflux symptoms such as “heartburn” and abdominal discomfort. Reflux may predispose patients to develop esophagitis and esophageal cancer. Gastric strangulation is the primary concern for those diagnosed with paraesophageal (type II) hiatal hernias. Both unilateral and bilateral diaphragmatic paralysis may be observed and, in a well-compensated patient, are compatible with normal activity. Diaphragmatic tumors are normally asymptomatic and found incidentally.
Diagnostics
Plain chest radiograph is diagnostic for diaphragmatic hernias, whereas computed tomography (CT), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), and ultrasound may play adjunctive roles. Congenital defects may be found on prenatal ultrasound. Contrast studies may also reveal important anatomy of acquired hiatal hernias. Diaphragmatic paralysis can be suggested by plain chest radiography as indicated by elevated diaphragmatic boarders. Fluoroscopic evaluation (“sniff test”) may also aid in the diagnosis of diaphragmatic paralysis. Recently, ultrasound evaluation of the diaphragm has become more common. Diaphragmatic tumors may be incidentally found with a number of modalities, and should be further evaluated using CT and MRI techniques.
Treatment
Operative repair for Bochdalek and Morgagni hernias require reducing herniated abdominal contents, resecting the hernia sac, and closing the diaphragmatic defect primarily or with a synthetic patch. Sliding (type I) hiatal hernias should first be addressed with medical management. Surgery is indicated for patients with recalcitrant symptoms, reflux complications, and signs of high-grade dysplasia in Barrett’s esophagus. Surgery aims to restore the GE junction to the abdomen and uses fundoplication to minimize reflux. Paraesophageal (type II) hiatal hernia requires surgical reduction of the proximal stomach, resection of the hernia sac, and diaphragmatic defect closure. Diaphragmatic paralysis is often transient, requiring no intervention. In the case of treatment, diaphragmatic placation may be required. Surgical resection of all diaphragmatic tumors is advocated and should include en bloc resection of surrounding pleural and peritoneal layers followed by defect closure.
Outcomes/prognosis
Repair of congenital diaphragmatic hernia is safe and usually successful. The morbidity and mortality associated with Bochdalek hernia are due to inadequate pulmonary development and pulmonary hypertension. Prompt repair in neonates with careful cardiopulmonary management has dramatically improved outcomes of the last 15 years. Surgical correction of acquired hiatal hernias is also associated with marked improvements and excellent long-term prognosis. Diaphragmatic paralysis usually resolves spontaneously within 1 year of injury. In the case of persistent paralysis, diaphragmatic plication is a well-tolerated procedure that produces both clinical and functional improvements. Surgical resection of benign diaphragmatic lesions is well tolerated; however, malignant lesions are associated with poor outcomes as recurrent disease is common.
The term “diaphragm” originates from the Greek words dia (in between) and phragma (fence). This reflects the diaphragm’s anatomical role in separating the torso into the thoracic and abdominal cavities. Functionally, the diaphragm is the principal muscle of respiration.
To review, embryologic development of the diaphragm is a process that occurs between the fourth and eighth week of gestation.1 The organ is formed by the fusion of tissues from four different sources. First, the septum transversum, a mass of mesodermal tissue located between the primitive heart tube and liver, gives rise to the central tendon of the diaphragm. This process produces two spaces (pleuroperitoneal canals) for the development of the lungs. As the lungs develop, they form bilateral folds, which fuse with the septum transversum to form bilateral pleuroperitoneal membranes.1 Myoblasts penetrate the pleuroperitoneal membranes to form the muscular part of the diaphragm. Also, the dorsal mesentery of the esophagus becomes invaded by myoblasts and ultimately forms the crura of the adult diaphragm. Finally, the body wall contributes portions to the peripheral diaphragm. During the fourth week of fetal development, the primitive diaphragm becomes innervated by the phrenic nerves (C3, C4, and C5). By week 8, the diaphragm descends as a result of displacement by the rapidly growing neural tube. A delay or alteration in the embryologic structuring can result in a diaphragmatic hernia or congenital eventration.
Anatomically, the diaphragm is skeletal muscle composed of two distinct parts—the costal and crural aspects.1 The costal muscle, located peripherally, is thin and causes downward displacement of the diaphragm. The costal part of the diaphragm allows the diaphragm to flatten and the lower ribs to lift, resulting in inspiration. The crural aspect of the diaphragm is thicker, supports the heart, and plays a lesser role in respiration. Both groups are innervated by the phrenic nerve. The pericardiacophrenic artery, musculophrenic artery, and superior phrenic arteries extend to the superior side of the diaphragm while the caudal area is supplied by the inferior phrenic arteries. The inferior phrenic arteries branch off the aortal hiatus directly from the aorta or from the celiac trunk. Direct branches of the aorta also vascularize the dorsal part of the diaphragm.
In the adult, the diaphragm is the primary muscle of inspiration and is responsible for 75 to 80 percent of the air brought into the lungs during quiet breathing.2 During light inspiration, the 2 domes of the diaphragm flatten to some extent, whereas the central tendon remains almost stationary. The diaphragm typically descends 1 to 2 cm during quiet breathing but may lower as much as 6 to 7 cm with forced inspiration. The peripheral parts of the diaphragm unwrap from the lateral walls of the chest by contraction during deep breathing. Both movements widen the costodiaphragmatic recesses, which the lungs subsequently expand to partially fill.
There are four hernias we will consider (Fig. 22-1): two congenital hernias (Bochdalek and Morgagni) and two acquired defects (sliding and paraesophageal).
Despite major advances in prenatal diagnosis and management, infants with Bochdalek diaphragmatic hernias diagnosed at birth (1/4000 live births) have a poor prognosis.3 Bochdalek hernia is a posterolateral hiatal defect in the diaphragm caused by a failure of the pleuroperitoneal canal fusion during fetal development. More than 80 percent occur in the left hemithorax, and typically are through a small circular defect (Fig. 22-2). Only 10 percent have a true hernia sac. When the intestines return to the abdomen from the yolk sac at 10 weeks gestation, the abdominal organs may herniate into the thorax through this defect. The pressure of abdominal viscera in the thoracic cavity results in a decrease in the number of bronchial branches, total number of acini, and number of vessels. Typically this results in impaired growth of the ipsilateral lung. However, in extreme cases, when the mediastinum is forced to the contralateral side of the chest, the contralateral lung may also be affected. Herniation of the viscera through the defect usually occurs during the pseudoglandular stage of lung development.
They are commonly associated with additional anomalies including congenital heart defects, hydronephrosis, renal agenesis, intestinal atresia, extralobular sequestration, hydrocephalus, anencephaly, and spina bifida.
Bochdalek hernias may result in life-threatening respiratory compromise as early as the first hours or days of life.3 The timing of presentation is dependent on the degree of pulmonary hypoplasia, which is the main cause of morbidity and mortality associated with this disorder. Occasionally, the defect may result in respiratory distress or feeding intolerance in later infancy or childhood or may be identified on a radiograph obtained for unrelated reasons. The other element that contributes to the pathophysiology of this disease is pulmonary hypertension—this condition mimics normal fetal circulation and is termed persistent fetal circulation. This condition may result in hypoxemia and acidosis (Fig. 22-3). Severe pulmonary hypertension forces right-to-left shunting through the persistent foramen ovale and the patent ductus arteriosus.
Almost 50 percent of these congenital diaphragmatic hernias are identified during prenatal ultrasound examination.4 The diagnosis can later be confirmed by a chest radiograph that characteristically demonstrates abdominal contents in the chest with mediastinal deviation away from the affected side (Fig. 22-4). The differential diagnosis includes congenital cystic adenomatoid malformation, other cystic diseases of the lung, and eventration of the diaphragm. Visualization of the naso- or oralgastric tube above the diaphragm also supports the diagnosis. The prenatal diagnosis of right-sided defects is extremely difficult because of the similar echogenicity of the liver and lung.
Figure 22-4
Chest x-ray of a neonate with a Bochdalek hernia. Chest radiograph demonstrate abdominal organs within the left hemithorax and mediastinal shift to the right. (Reproduced with permission from Kaplan JA, Slinger PD. Thoracic Anesthesia, 3rd ed. Philadelphia: Churchill Livingstone, 2003:355. Copyright Elsevier.)
If a patient presents with respiratory distress at birth, the child should be promptly intubated and nasogastric decompression initiated to minimize visceral distention. Mechanical ventilation with 100 percent Fio2 and low airway pressures (<25 mm Hg and 5 of positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP)) should be used. The patient should then be transported to a facility capable of extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO). Indication to place a baby on ECMO includes an alveolar–arterial oxygen gradient greater than 600 for 8 h, oxygen index greater than 40, pH <7.15, Pao2 <55, and progressive barotrauma. ECMO is contraindicated if the patient has preexisting weights less than 2 kg, intraventricular hemorrhage, or has other abnormalities incompatible with life.
Repair of a Bocadaleck hernia has previously been considered a surgical emergency; however, the scheme of emergency operative repair immediately after birth has resulted in mortality rates greater than 50 percent. Recent trends include alternative forms of management, such as delayed operation, ECMO, inhaled nitric oxide, and partial liquid ventilation, all with improved results. Recent studies have demonstrated preoperative stabilization results in improvement of pulmonary compliance prior to repair.4 Once stable, the repair can be performed through a paramedian incision or subcostal incision. A transthoracic approach has also been advocated by some for right-sided hernias. From the abdominal approach, the viscera can be returned from the chest and the hernia sac may need to be excised if present. The lung tissue should be examined; however, attempts to expand the hypoplastic lung should be avoided. Extralobar pulmonary sequestrations are resected at the time of hernia repair.
A small diaphragmatic defect is closed with permanent suture and Teflon pledgets. Larger defects, or defects whose edges may be under tension, can be closed with synthetic sheet material. Typically, bilateral chest tubes are left in place and connected to water-seal. Intra-abdominal anomalies may be corrected at the time of hernia repair if the patient’s condition is stable, although there remain center-to-center preferences regarding this step. In some cases, abdominal wall fascia may not be closed primarily and these circumstances should be managed as large abdominal wall defects.
Postoperative management should aim to reduce pulmonary vascular resistance, improve oxygenation, and treat persistent fetal circulation. Frequent arterial blood gas determinations coupled with continuous pulse oximetry or transcutaneous partial pressure of oxygen and carbon dioxide monitoring provide a reliable mechanism of ventilatory status. A variety of vasodilators have been used to prevent and reverse pulmonary hypertension. It is important to realize that minor changes in ventilation can precipitate intense pulmonary vasoconstriction. Finally, one should consider that the lungs are at risk of barotrauma. As a last resort, ECMO may need to be initiated to reverse pulmonary hypertension if conventional methods fail.
In the absence of additional lethal anomalies, mortality is directly related to the degree of pulmonary hypoplasia. Other prognostic indications associated with poor outcome include additional anomalies, polyhydramnios, presence of an intrathoracic stomach bubble, and underdevelopment of the left heart region. Although the majority of these patients present within the first few days of life, patients may present later in life. This cohort of patients often presents with a variety of respiratory symptoms or sometimes bowel obstruction.
Morgagni hernia was initially described by Morgagni in 1769. Morgagni hernias are rare and account for less than 5 percent of all diaphragmatic hernias. Unlike Bochdalek hernias, patients with Morgagni hernias typically present later in life.3 Morgagni hernias are hypothesized to arise from the incomplete fusion of the transverse septum to fuse with the sternum and resulting abnormalities of the foramen of Morgagni (Fig. 22-2). These hernias typically are true hernias and possess a hernia sac. Commonly, the defect contains a piece of omentum that enlarges as the person grows and produces the mass within the hernia sac. However, colon and small intestine are capable of passing through larger defects. A right-sided defect occurs in 90 percent of the cases because the left side is protected by the pericardium.