Author
Year of publication
Patientsa
Years
Morbidity (%)
30 day mortality (%)
5-year survival (%)
Jensik et al. [1]
1982
34
1964–1981
29
15
Watanabe et al. [2]
1990
12
17
NR
Mathisen and Grillo et al. [3]
1991
37
1973–1991
19
19
Roviaro et al. [4]
1994
28
1983–1992
4
20
Ayabe et al. [5]
1995
15
1957–1993
93
13.3
NR
Dartevelle et al. [6]
1996
60
7
43
Mitchell et al. [7]
1999
58
1962–1996
15.5
Mitchell et al. [8]
2001
60
1973–1998
15
42
Porhanov [9]
2002
151
1979–2001
35.6b
16b
24.7
Regnard et al. [10]
2005
65
1983–2002
51
7.7
26.5
de Perrot et al. [11]
2006
103
1981–2004
47
7.8
44
Macchiarini et al. [12]
2006
50
1999–2004
37
4
51
Yamamoto et al. [13]
2007
35
1987–2004
22.8
8.5
28.3
Rea et al. [14]
2008
49
1982–2005
28.6
6.1
27.5
Jiang et al. [15]
2009
41
1982–2006
2.4
26.8
Technical Considerations
The technical aspects of carinal resection have been well described elsewhere [3, 7, 12] and are beyond the scope of this article. There is some variability in anesthetic and surgical technique between centers that deserves mention.
Anesthetic Technique
Various ventilation techniques during carinal resection have been described including sterile cross-field ventilation [8, 11], high-frequency jet ventilation (HFJV) [9, 10, 14], and apneic hyperoxygenation [12]. Because most reports of carinal resection come from single institutions, comparative studies have not been conducted. There may be an increased rate of acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) with HFJV [9] although this observation has not been supported by other groups [10]. Planned cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) is not routinely required and emergency use of CPB is uncommon [11]. There may be a decreased incidence of barotrauma-related ARDS with apneic hyperoxygenation [12].
Choice of Approach
For anatomic reasons, right-sided carinal resections are more common than left-sided procedures [7, 11]. Whereas right-sided carinal resection is approached preferably via right posterolateral thoracotomy, the much less common left-sided carinal resection may be approached via left thoracotomy or bilateral anterior thoracotomy [7]. Median sternotomy [11, 12] affords access to carinal resection alone and to resections combined with right or left parenchymal resections.
Anastomotic Considerations
In order to achieve a tension-free anastomosis, the majority of authors limit tracheobronchial resection to 4 cm [7, 11, 15]. This distance refers to the maximal resectable airway length that still allows acceptable tension between trachea and left main bronchus. Hilar release of the left main stem bronchus by pericardial circumcision of the pulmonary veins is useful to reduce anastomotic tension but laryngeal release does not transfer additional tracheal length to the carina [11]. The use of a guardian stitch (a stitch between the chin and anterior chest wall to prevent neck extension postoperatively) varies among institutions. Anastomotic complications increase with each additional anastomosis; end-to-side reimplantation of a main or intermedius bronchus has a greater incidence of leak and separation. Variation in postoperative morbidity and mortality by length of trachea resected is not described in these series. At least 13 configurations for reconstructing the carina have been described [7] and the choice of anastomosis is dictated by the anatomy of the individual resection.
Resection of Additional Mediastinal Structures
Resection and reconstruction of various other mediastinal structures including the pulmonary artery, left atrium and superior vena cava were included in several series [11, 14, 15]. Evidence for increased mortality with more extensive resections is not presented but may be assumed if vascular anastomoses are added. Involvement of these structures by the primary tumor is not a contraindication to carinal resection.
Postoperative Considerations
The most frequent causes of early postoperative death in these series were anastomotic complication and respiratory failure due to ARDS. The mortality of anastomotic dehiscence or ARDS approach or exceed 50 % [11, 13]. A higher incidence of anastomotic complications appears to correlate with operative mortality (Table 45.2). Greater anastomotic complexity must therefore be balanced with the aim to preserve lung parenchyma. In the majority of published cases a viable tissue wrap (usually pericardium or intercostal muscle) is used to protect the anastomosis [7, 14, 15]. Comparative rates of anastomotic dehiscence or stenosis with or without a wrap are not described.
Table 45.2
Incidence of anastomotic complications and operative mortality