The purposes of this study were to characterize the morphologic, imaging, and clinical characteristics of double-inlet, double-outlet right ventricle (DI-DORV), a rare congenital heart disease, and to compare these findings to those in patients with double-inlet left ventricle (DILV). The clinical records, imaging studies, and heart specimens of 22 consecutive patients with DI-DORV were reviewed. A comparison group of 44 patients with DILV was matched by age at latest follow-up. Among the 22 patients with DI-DORV, 14 had clinical data, 5 had clinical and autopsy data, and 3 had only autopsy data. Abdominal and atrial situs were normal in all, and heart position was levocardia in 91%. The morphology of the atrioventricular valves was variable, with 15 patients showing neither a typical tricuspid nor mitral valve. In the remaining 7 patients, 1 or both atrioventricular valves resembled a tricuspid or a mitral valve. Myocardial architecture was characterized by atypical muscle bundles of varying degrees of hypertrophy and orientation. Most patients had bilateral conus, and 82% had either aortic or pulmonary outflow tract obstructions. The rate of overall mortality or heart transplantation was 36%. Significant differences between DI-DORV and DILV included the type of ventricular loop, the type of conus, and a higher mortality rate in patients with DI-DORV. In conclusion, DI-DORV is a distinct type of functional single ventricle congenital heart disease with variable atrioventricular valve morphology and myocardial architecture. Accurate diagnosis using noninvasive imaging techniques is of paramount importance for optimal management.
Functional single ventricle (FSV) congenital heart disease comprises a heterogenous group of cardiac anomalies for which surgical palliation resulting in biventricular circulation is judged not to be feasible. Among the anatomic variants of FSV, most cases with functional single right ventricle comprise hypoplastic left heart syndrome and right ventricular (RV)–dominant common atrioventricular (AV) canal. Double-inlet, double-outlet right ventricle (DI-DORV) is a rare form of FSV congenital cardiac anomaly that has been mentioned in published reports only anecdotally. These reports do not characterize the anatomy and diagnostic imaging features of this condition in detail. Previously, published reports have suggested that DI-DORV is a distinct anatomic entity that is challenging to diagnose because of the unusual morphology of the RV myocardium, with hypertrophied muscle bars that can be mistaken for a ventricular septum. Inaccurate diagnosis of this condition as multiple ventricular septal defects can have important implications for catheter-based or surgical management. This study was undertaken to characterize the morphologic, imaging, and clinical characteristics of DI-DORV in 22 consecutive patients and to compare these findings with those of patients with double-inlet left ventricle (DILV).
Methods
Standard definitions of ventricular morphology were used to identify the right ventricle and the left ventricle. DI-DORV was defined as congenital heart disease in which 2 distinct AV valves commit exclusively to the right ventricle and/or the infundibulum, and the aorta and main pulmonary artery are also aligned with the right ventricle and/or the infundibulum. The presence of a left ventricular (LV) cavity was allowed, provided no AV valve was attached to it and no great artery arose from it. Also, atresia of the aortic or pulmonary outflow tract was allowed, as long as the corresponding vessel was spatially aligned with the right ventricle or with the infundibulum. Straddling or common AV valve was considered an exclusion criterion.
Cases were ascertained by a query of the cardiac registry in the Department of Pathology and the electronic database of the Cardiovascular Program at Children’s Hospital Boston from 1950 through June 2007. Cardiac specimens, fetal and postnatal echocardiograms, cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR), cardiac angiography, and medical record data were reviewed. The Children’s Hospital Committee on Clinical Investigations approved the review of specimens, imaging studies, and medical records.
Specimens were systematically reviewed for segmental anatomy, cardiac position (classified as levocardia, dextrocardia, or mesocardia), systemic and pulmonary venous connections, AV valve morphology, RV myocardial architecture, the presence of an LV cavity, the type of conus (classified as subpulmonary, subaortic, bilateral, or bilaterally absent), aortic and pulmonary outflow tract obstructions, great vessel anomalies, and associated anomalies.
All available fetal and postnatal echocardiograms, CMR, and cardiac catheterization angiograms were analyzed for the same anatomic details as in the specimen review. In addition, ventricular function, AV valve stenosis and/or regurgitation, and semilunar valve function were assessed on all preoperative studies.
The following clinical data were abstracted from patients’ medical record: date of birth, gender, associated noncardiac anomalies, surgical and catheter-based procedures, arrhythmias, and clinical outcomes.
To compare morphologic and outcome characteristics of DI-DORV with those of DILV, patients with the latter diagnosis were randomly selected from the electronic database of the Cardiovascular Program. For each patient with DI-DORV, 2 patients with DILV matched by age at latest follow-up were selected.
Categorical data were compared using Fisher’s exact test and are expressed as number (percentage). Continuous data are expressed as median (range), and comparisons between groups were made using the Mann-Whitney U test. Statistical analyses were performed using Stata version 10.1 (StataCorp LP, College Station, Texas). A p value <0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Results
Among the 22 patients with DI-DORV, 19 had clinical and imaging data, and the remaining 3 only had heart specimens available for review. Of the 19 patients with clinical records, 5 subsequently died and had autopsies, bringing the number of heart specimens included in the study to 8. The incidence of DI-DORV in our autopsy material was 8 in 3,849 (0.2%) and in our clinical experience 19 in 205,786 patients (0.009%, or 1 in nearly 11,000). The demographic characteristics, diagnostic methods, and pertinent clinical and outcomes data of the study patients are listed in Table 1 . The median age at diagnosis was 1 day (range 0 to 180) and the median length of follow-up of the 19 patients with clinical records was 3.2 years (range 0 to 33). The male/female ratio was 1.3.
Patient | Age at Diagnosis (years) | Gender | Diagnostic Methods | Initial Palliation | Final Palliation | Age at Outcome (years) | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 0 | F | E, C, Au | Transcatheter septation | Same | 0.4 | Death |
2 | 0.5 | M | E, A | BT shunt | Fontan, pacemaker | 33 | Death (liver cirrhosis) |
3 | 0 | M | E, Au | Stage I Norwood | Same | 0.3 | Heart transplantation |
4 | N/A | F | Au | BT shunt | Same | 17 | Death (brain abscess) |
5 | 0 | M | Au | BT shunt | Central shunt | 1.0 | Death (RDS) |
6 | 0 | M | Au | None | Same | 0.1 | Death (heart failure) |
7 | 0 | F | Au | None | Same | 0.1 | Death |
8 | N/A | N/A | Au | None | Same | N/A | Death |
9 | 0 | M | E | PA band | BDG, ASD creation | 0.7 | Alive (heart failure) |
10 | 0 | F | E, C | Stage I Norwood | Fontan | 2.5 | Alive |
11 | 0 | M | E, C, CMR | BT shunt | BDG, ASD creation | 2.2 | Alive (asymptomatic) |
12 | 0.2 | F | E, CMR | BT shunt | Fontan | 50 | Alive (heart failure) |
13 | 0 | F | E, C, fe, CMR | BDG, MPA ligation | Fontan | 9.5 | Alive (asymptomatic) |
14 | 0 | F | E, C, fe, CMR | BDG, TV repair, ASD creation | Fontan, AVV repair | 6.5 | Alive (asymptomatic) |
15 | 0 | M | E, C, fe | BT shunt | Fontan | 6.6 | Alive (asymptomatic) |
16 | 0 | M | E, C, fe | PA band | Fontan | 3.2 | Alive (asymptomatic) |
17 | 0 | M | E, C, CMR | PA band, coarctation repair | Fontan | 25 | Alive (asymptomatic) |
18 | 0 | M | E, C, fe | BT shunt | Fontan | 4.5 | Alive (asymptomatic) |
19 | 0 | F | E, C, fe | Ventricular septation, coarctation repair | MVR, modified Konno, repeat “VSD” closure | 3.3 | Alive (ventricular dysfunction) |
20 | 0 | F | E | Stage I Norwood, IAA repair | Fontan | 15 | Alive (asymptomatic) |
21 | 0 | M | E | PA band | ASD creation, PA band revision | 1.9 | Alive (asymptomatic) |
22 | 0.2 | M | E, C | BDG | Same | 0.6 | Alive (asymptomatic) |
Several initial palliative procedures were performed in the 19 patients with clinical records, including systemic artery–to–pulmonary artery shunting in 7, pulmonary artery banding in 4, stage I Norwood procedures in 3, bidirectional Glenn shunting in 3, and ventricular septation in 2 ( Table 1 ). At latest follow-up, 13 patients had FSV palliation with modified Fontan procedures (n = 10) or bidirectional Glenn shunting (n = 3). Additional surgical procedures were performed in 5 patients. Overall mortality (n = 4) in the 19 clinically followed patients was 21%. An additional patient underwent heart transplantation. Among all patients with DI-DORV in this series, 15 (68%) were alive at latest follow-up.
Ventricular septation was attempted in 2 patients. Patient 1 was initially diagnosed with DORV and multiple large ventricular septal defects and underwent transcatheter device closure of the supposed muscular defects at age 4 months in anticipation of subsequent biventricular surgical repair. The patient developed complete heart block, low cardiac output, and multiple organ failure and died 3 days after the procedure. Patient 19 was initially diagnosed with a markedly deficient ventricular septum, excessive LV trabeculations, and aortic coarctation. Surgery consisted of closure of the supposed ventricular septal defects and aortic coarctation repair and was complicated by severe ventricular dysfunction and mitral regurgitation requiring mitral valve repair at age 3 months, followed by mitral valve replacement at age 4 months. The patient underwent 2 subsequent operations to relieve recurrent aortic outflow obstruction and was alive with ventricular dysfunction at age 1 year.
Table 2 lists the anatomic characteristics of the study patients. Abdominal and atrial situs were normal in all. Levocardia was present in 20 (91%) and dextrocardia in patients 3 and 4 (9%). Of the 22 patients, the type of ventricular loop could not be determined in 17 (77%) because the location of the ventricular septum could not be ascertained in the absence of an LV cavity. In those cases, the ventricular loop was designated “X,” indicating unknown ventricular loop ( Table 2 ). In the remaining 5 patients, the presence of a small, posteriorly located LV cavity allowed the determination of ventricular looping: right-handed in 4 and left-handed in 1.
Patient | Source of Data | Segmental Anatomy ⁎ | AVV Characteristics | RV Myocardial Architecture | LV Cavity | Outflow Obstruction | Additional Anatomic Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Autopsy, imaging | (S,X,D) | Both TV morph; LAVV opens to inf; RAVV opens to VS | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations | 0 | 0 | Bilaterally trilobed lungs |
2 | Autopsy, imaging | (S,X,D) | Both TV morph; LAVV stenosis; RAVV attach to MB and FW | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations | 0 | Acquired pulm atresia | LSVC; supramitral ring |
3 | Autopsy, imaging | (S,D,S) | Indeterminate morph; LAVV stenosis; RAVV myxomatous | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations | Post and left | Aortic atresia | LSVC |
4 | Autopsy | (S,L,L) | LAVV TV morph; RAVV indeterminate morph | Large, Y-shaped SB; prominent apical trabeculations | Post and right | SubPS; PS | LSVC |
5 | Autopsy | (S,X,L) | LAVV TV morph; RAVV MV morph with stenosis | Prominent apical trabeculations coalescing to a prominent SB | 0 | Pulm atresia | Discontinuous PAs |
6 | Autopsy | (S,X,D) | Indeterminate morph; LAVV stenosis; RAVV double orifice | Large SB dividing right ventricle into right 2/3 and left 1/3 | 0 | SubAS, AS | Coarctation |
7 | Autopsy | (S,X,D) | LAVV MV morph; RAVV TV morph | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations | 0 | AS | Hypoplastic AA; cor triatriatum |
8 | Autopsy | (S,D,D) | Indeterminate morph; RAVV quadrileaflet | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations | Post and left | 0 | Single LCA |
9 | Imaging | (S,X,D) | Indeterminate morph; LAVV stenosis; both AVV attach to MB | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations; free-floating SB | 0 | SubPS; PS | |
10 | Imaging | (S,X,L) | Both TV morph; RAVV attach to MB | Multiple coarse noncoalescing apical trabeculations | 0 | SubPS; PS | Coarctation |
11 | Imaging | (S,X,L) | Indeterminate morph; both AVV attach to MB | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations; free-floating SB | 0 | SubPS; PS | RAA |
12 | Imaging | (S,X,A) | Indeterminate morph; angled AVV annular planes | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations | 0 | SubPS; PS | LSVC |
13 | Imaging | (S,X,A) | Indeterminate morph; LAVV attaches to MB and FW | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations; free-floating SB | 0 | SubPS; PS | |
14 | Imaging | (S,X,L) | Indeterminate morph; RAVV thickened | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations | 0 | SubPS; PS | RAA |
15 | Imaging | (S,X,L) | LAVV MV morph; RAVV TV morph | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations | 0 | Pulm atresia | Secundum ASD |
16 | Imaging | (S,X,D) | LAVV stenosis; multiple accessory chordae of both AVVs | Prominent apical trabeculations coalescing to a prominent SB | 0 | 0 | Single LCA |
17 | Imaging | (S,D,D) | Indeterminate morph | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations | Post and left | 0 | Coarctation; secundum ASD |
18 | Imaging | (S,X,D) | Indeterminate morph; LAVV stenosis | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations | 0 | SubPS; PS | |
19 | Imaging | (S,X,D) | LAVV cleft with attach to inf; both AVV attach to MB | Large MB at apex | 0 | AS | Coarctation |
20 | Imaging | (S,D,D) | Indeterminate morph; LAVV stenosis | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations | Post | SubAS | Type A IAA |
21 | Imaging | (S,X,D) | Indeterminate morph; both AVV attach to MB | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations; large post MB | 0 | 0 | Secundum ASD |
22 | Imaging | (S,X,D) | Indeterminate morph; RAVV prolapse | Multiple noncoalescing apical trabeculations | 0 | SubPS; PS | LSVC; left JAA |
⁎ See Van Praagh for explanation of symbols of segmental anatomy.
The AV valves in all patients exhibited structural abnormalities varying from mild myxomatous thickening to severe hypoplasia and/or marked redundancy with accessory leaflet tissue and chordae tendineae ( Figure 1 ). Moreover, the attachments of the AV valves of all patients were abnormal, most commonly with attachments of both valves to a muscle band of varying thickness located between the valves ( Figure 2 ). In most patients (n = 15 [68%]), neither AV valve resembled a tricuspid or a mitral valve. In the remaining 7 patients, 1 or both AV valves resembled a tricuspid or a mitral valve ( Figure 2 , Table 2 ). Functional assessment of the AV valves by preoperative echocardiography found mild regurgitation of 1 or both AV valves in 10 of 15 patients (67%) and moderate regurgitation of the right AV valve in 1 of 15 (7%).